Three bodies are discovered in a burned-out home in Scottsdale, and a fourth family member is missing. Investigators realize they have a triple homicide on their hands, and embark on a decades-long manhunt for the killer.
In a small town in Florida, a charismatic pastor and his wife take in a young woman from their congregation, and months later they announce her as a surrogate for their child; when she disappears, the true story begins to emerge.
Police find a family savagely murdered in their quiet suburban Oklahoma home, but when police find a victim still clinging to life and able to provide some answers, they launch a desperate search for the perpetrators before they can kill again.
Amina and Sarah Said long to live the lives of typical American teenagers, but when they push back against the rules of their traditionalist father, tensions simmer inside the family and come to an explosive conclusion.
In rural Kentucky, police receive a distressing call about the brutal killing of a family in their home. Authorities learn the victim’s son is the sole survivor of the attack by a disgruntled ex-handyman, but his recollection of the murder doesn’t add up.
In small-town upstate New York, a young mother loses her five-year old son who's battled a medical condition that has plagued him since birth; doctors claim his death is not from a natural cause, and investigators soon suspect foul play.