When Alex (Amanda Peet) is invited to a wedding at her boss Bob's (guest star Larry Miller) home, she invites Ben (guest star Matt Letscher), hoping he can aid in her efforts to impress the partner's wives. When a last-minute emergency arises, Ben is forced to leave and Pete (David Walton) comes in to try and save the day. Meanwhile, Screwsie (Margo Harshman) is offered the catering job for the wedding and enlists Walt's (Jeffrey Tambor) help. Elsewhere, Alex's necklace goes missing and the crew falls under suspicion.