Stephanie and Ryan are looking for a fully loaded Charlotte, North Carolina home. But while she's a high-maintenance property virgin with a long list of must-haves, Ryan's only requirement is a man cave for himself. Enter property expert Egypt Sherrod. She promises to find them a home they will both love. But finding some middle ground may be tricky since Stephanie vows from the start that she simply isn't willing to compromise. After touring house after house, it doesn't look like any home will suit Stephanie. That is, until the couple makes a surprise decision and their search takes a dramatic turn.