Olivia has known Joe since high school, when the two shared a disastrous prom night. Now a first-year law student living in Staten Island, Olivia recruits Antonella, one of Enoteca Maria’s nonnas-turned-professional chefs, and helps Joe with the legal side of his restaurant. No stranger to the healing salve of a nonna’s cooking, Olivia reminds Joe and the nonnas that it’s never too late to start over.