While in Florida caring for her ailing father, Athena and Bobby investigate the disappearance of her childhood friend from 45 years ago.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lyndsey Beaulieu | Writer | ||
| Chauncey Jenkins | Guest Star | Young Samuel | |
| Beverly Todd | Guest Star | Beatrice Carter | |
| Chris Devlin | Guest Star | Sheriff Hayers | |
| Kevyn Morrow | Guest Star | Junior Franklin | |
| Kapri Ladd | Guest Star | Tanya Kingston | |
| Henry G. Sanders | Guest Star | Samuel Carter | |
| Alejandro Furth | Guest Star | Dr. Pino | |
| Darrell Lake | Guest Star | Young Reggie | |
| Donzaleigh Abernathy | Guest Star | Joanne Kingston | |
| Ayaamii Sledge | Guest Star | 9-year-old Athens | |
| Brianna Reed | Guest Star | Teen Joanne | |
| Lou Beatty Jr. | Guest Star | Reggie Franklin Sr. | |
| Deanne Lauvin | Guest Star | Young Beatrice | |
| Angela K. Thomas | Guest Star | Patrice Kingston | |
| Reggie Watkins | Guest Star | Detective Clifford Dixon | |
| Steven K. Tsuchida | Director |