Amy invites the winner of the "Biggest Fan Essay Contest" to co-host. But as she shares her kitchen and craft room with contest winner Mary from Two Points, it becomes clear that Mary has her eyes on something much more than co-hosting.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paul Dinello | Writer | ||
| Cole Escola | Writer | ||
| Allison Silverman | Writer | ||
| Amy Sedaris | Writer | ||
| Miriam Tolan | Guest Star | ||
| Rose Byrne | Guest Star | ||
| Cole Escola | Guest Star | ||
| Sondra James | Guest Star | ||
| Bill Benz | Director |