Dawson und Jen kehren vom New Hampshire-Filmfestival zurück. Das erste Aufeinandertreffen mit ihren Freunden findet im Haus von Jens Großmutter statt, wo sich Pacey redlich bemüht ein gutes Abendessen zuzubereiten. Schnell ist allen klar, dass Dawsons und Jens Freundschaft nicht länger platonischer Art ist.
Pacey offers to cook for the gang on their weekly dinner (an event they always plan on doing but always fail to). Jen and Dawson return early and decide to keep what happened between them, but they are caught by everyone making out at the door. The dinner goes on in a very awkward way for everyone as Audrey and Dawson worry about Joey. But surprisingly she seems to be fine with it. Charlie also drops by, causing some tension for Dawson. At the end, they all decide that keeping their long lasting friendships is more important than having a weekly dinner, and Joey confesses to Pacey how she really feels about the whole Dawson-Jen thing.
Tout le monde est stupéfait d'apprendre que Dawson et Jennifer ont décidé de retourner à Boston.
Pacey organise un dîner pour tous ses amis...
Dopo essere rientrati, Dawson e Jen partecipano a una cena durante la quale la loro relazione diventa di dominio pubblico.
Pacey decide fazer um jantar na casa da avó de Jen, na tentativa de reaproximar seus amigos, mas as coisas fogem do controle quando Joey se surpreende ao ver Dawson e Jen se beijando. O jantar continua de uma maneira muito estranha para todos, enquanto Audrey e Dawson se preocupam com Joey. Charlie visita Jen, causando alguma tensão com Dawson. Joey confessa a Pacey como ela realmente se sente sobre a coisa toda de Dawson e Jen.
Dawson y Jen vuelven a casa para encontrarse con una cena inesperada en la cual se descubre repentinamente su relación.
