A story from the past sheds light on the teens' current predicament.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nick Mueller | Writer | ||
| Christine Willes | Guest Star | Madame Zelda | |
| Jonathan Silverman | Guest Star | Perry Biddle | |
| William Chris Sumpter | Guest Star | Young Ben | |
| Chris Geere | Guest Star | Slappy | |
| Gillian Vigman | Guest Star | Georgia Biddle | |
| Taylar Hender | Guest Star | Young Nora | |
| Kaylah Zander | Guest Star | Betsy | |
| Eddie Jemison | Guest Star | Ephraim Biddle | |
| Michelle Mao | Guest Star | Young Victoria | |
| Lisa Durupt | Guest Star | Rhonda | |
| Ben Cockell | Guest Star | Harold Biddle | |
| Samantha Blaire Cutler | Guest Star | Young Eliza | |
| Natalie Moon | Guest Star | Dietrich | |
| Alex Felix | Guest Star | Young Sarah | |
| Félix Enríquez Alcalá | Director |