SpongeBob is unclogging his toilet, until the plunger gets stuck in place. He tries to pull it out but it ends up his arm jammed into the toilet. He pulls it out of the toilet, but at the cost of the skin on his hand. He clinches his mutilated limb and slowly walks back, but he trips on a toy train in the process. His back hits his sink, causing his mirror to open up and release a bunch of sharp items onto SpongeBob's face, injuring it. Back to the toilet, it propels the plunger that had been previously sucked into it, which hits SpongeBob and impales his forehead, forcing his brain out.
Sonic is nonchalantly running at night, but after he runs past by Cuddles and Toothy, who are playing with a match, he is set on fire. He then runs over Cub, who was playing with an axe, which gets lodged in Sonic's forehead. After seeing his son's death, Pop plots revenge against Sonic. The blue hedgehog then runs into Kirby driving his motor scooter, causing him to be launched into the air and land into a house resided by Chef Pee Pee. Kirby's motor scooter then falls onto the back of Chef Pee Pee's head, shredding apart his skull until it drives out of it, up a wall, and into a pendant lamp, leading to Kirby being electrocuted. Meanwhile, Pop stirs up an angry mob against Sonic, while also hiring Handy and Kyle's mom to build a wall in Sonic's path with the intent to kill him. Sonic eventually runs into the wall, but it explodes with him, sending one of the bricks at Pop, which takes out a massive chunk of his head.
Kirby discovers a Miracle Fruit and eats it, transforming him into his Hypernova form. He proceeds to go on a rampage and devour anything in his way.
Splendid was taking a sip of his coffee until he is alerted by Mrs. Cartman's scream, who is being ambushed by Lifty and Shifty. Splendid comes to the rescue and kills both raccoons. The victim shows gratitude for Splendid but as soon as the superhero flew out of sight, Mrs. Cartman's skin is torn off of her body. Splendid now has to deal with a fire coming from Kirby's house, but it leads to calamity when he tries to put it out. However, Splendid gets an idea and punches a lone Chilly to freeze the mass fire. This attempt causes the snowman to burst into an icy explosion, which leads to the town covered in snow and most of the civilizations frozen in ice.
Lumpy sets out a bucket of toxic waste out on his front yard and Cuddles decides to drink it out of curiosity, which transforms him into a zombie. After the zombification, Cuddles goes on a rampage and kills nearby victims. However, his reign of terror is finally stopped by Lumpy, who bashes in Cuddles' head with a club.
This episode is a retelling of the SpongeBob SquarePants episode "Home Sweet Pineapple". However, instead of simply living with Patrick, after SpongeBob sets himself under Patrick's rock, the weight of the giant object crushes him. When he tries to free himself from his predicament, he is torn from his lower half, resulting in his (still intact) intestines spilling out. He later dies from blood loss after an entire day has passed.
Pop takes notice of his house's poor condition as it falls apart, so he hires Kirby The Handyman to repair it. However, as Kirby begins to hammer in a nail, Cuddles and SpongeBob's fireworks is set off, startling Kirby and making him stab his eye with the hammer, which provokes a chain of events that leaves Kirby with more injuries, including being ripped apart by a fan, skinned alive, set on fire, mauled by a dog, and finally, run over by Lumpy, who then crashes his car into Handy, leading to chain reaction of car crashes that subsequently explodes and sends Lumpy flying into the air. Lumpy crashes down and breaks the lower-half of his torso in the process, only to be impaled in the skull by a steering wheel.
Winter has come around for the Toons, and as such, a ski race is being held. SpongeBob is one of the contesters, but is worried about it. Unfortunately, Cuddles accidentally throws a snowball at SpongeBob, knocking him down mountains and landscapes. As SpongeBob is no longer in control of his direction, he ends up causing disaster among fellow skiers and himself, which involves SpongeBob being electrocuted by a power line, falling down multiple hills, having an eye being pierced by a branch, killing several other Toons, and a giant snowball being formed, which runs several more Toons, causes Disco Bear's death, and finally runs over SpongeBob. SpongeBob pops out of the snowball barely alive, only for a ski stick to pierce his skull and a snowball to freeze his body, which subsequently shatters.
Mrs. Stotch and Pop have decided to go onto a road trip. They brought along some bratty kids, however, specifically Eric Cartman and Stewie Griffin along with a well-behaved SpongeBob. Stewie and Cartman got into a fight, causing them to annoy Mrs. Stotch into a fit of rage.
Chef Pee Pee gets into a freak accident and suffers from third degree burns, which requires him to wear bandages over his eyes. This serves as a hindrance to his cooking, as he unknowingly mutilates the costumers during the process of trying to navigate the kitchen.
This video is an animated version of another YouTube video titled "The Wario Greentext Story".
Eric Cartman is somehow in possession of a long knife and decides to use it for a lethal stunt involving Kirby. Afterwards, he pours gasoline and throws a match onto Kirby's sliced remains to dispose of it, though he is delighted by the smell of Kirby's burning corpse. He grabs a knife and fork as he prepares to eat the remains, though the match previously thrown onto the remains now had engulfed the entirety of it into flames and then subsequently explodes, leaving Cartman to be nothing but a skeleton. His eating utensils flies into the air and then impales Petunia in the face, smashing her brains out.
While during bookclub, Pop is reminded of his precious beer that he was going to initially drink. However, Wario decides to swipe his beverage and drink it himself, infuriating Pop. SpongeBob is asked by Pop for help to retrieve the beer Wario has in his hand and agrees. Afterward, SpongeBob and Pop began trying various methods to reclaim Pop's beer.
SpongeBob tries to catch a jellyfish, but King Dedede knocks him down a hill, putting SpongeBob and others into mayhem.
Lumpy is tasked with babysitting Kenny McCormick but doesn't how to properly treat his injuries.
Squidward tries to escape a lustful Meg while SpongeBob and Cuddles struggle with gymnastic sports.
Wario flips off a familar dog, only to suffer dearly for it.
After having his burger stolen by Kirby, Mr. Krabs gives chase.
The characters are placed in a scenario based on Among Us, where they are trying to catch an onboard killer.
After Plankton escape from prison, he finds himself eaten by SpongeBob when he hides inside a Krabby Patty. Trying to rescue Plankton and escape from the feline-like Gary, Jerry follows suit.
Roaming the streets with an empty stomach, Nutty groans to himself from starvation. However, he notices Toothy licking a lollipop, causing Nutty to pester the beaver over his sweet.
Homer Simpson is roasting a turkey improperly, leading to the smoke detector going off. In a hasty attempt to prevent the fire, Homer ends up having his arm catch on fire also. He sprints outside in pain, until he was hit by a car, sending him into a tree branch that impales him. Meanwhile, Pop ends up killing several predestrians while drunk driving.
King Dedede gives chase to Wario over a bag of money. No matter the King's efforts, Wario manages to come up on top. At least until Dedede calls for reinforcements.
SpongeBob and Patrick competes in a sports race derby against their arch-nemesis, Plankton and his abettor, King Dedede, alongside other racers. This soon leads to a disastrous chain of events.
Larry Koopa, Kenny McCormick, and Cuddles go trick-or-treating until they stumble across Flippy's house.
SpongeBob is running a bit late for his date with Giggles, so he resorts to stealing Handy's car and getting into hasty traffic.
Stan Marsh sees a kitten with its tail trapped by a bear trap. He tries to pull open the bear trap, with brief success, allowing the kitten to be free and hop away. Unfortunately, the beartrap overpowers Stan and clamps both of his arms off. Stan yells in horror and eventually faints from blood loss, causing him to fall backward into the bear trap.
Flippy is invited over at Pop's house.
Clyde Donovan tries to impress Wendy Testaburger.
Mayor McDaniels was kidnapped and Pop chases after her into the world of Super Mario Bros.
Cartman and his friends dare Kenny to drive over a seemingly homeless Mole.
Flippy now works at a construction site, which could only go so well.
Several characters are seen inside a gumball machine. Patrick inserts a coin and SpongeBob is the one to drop out. Patrick tosses SpongeBob into his mouth and starts to chew him up. Upon seeing this, the remaining characters panic and frantically try to escape from the gumball machine.
SpongeBob is hammering a nail into the floor.
Pop is greatly injured at the hospital and needs to take his shot.
Pop was about to chuck a bomb as mischief, only to be interrupted by Twitter notifications.
A marathon that consists of every Halloween special in Gory Toons up to this point. Before the marathon, a small short featuring Clyde Donovan and Craig Tucker plays, where Clyde asks a reluctant Craig for some of his Halloween candy. As Clyde swallows the candy, he chokes on the candy and dies.