When both men want an exclusive commitment from Faith, she resorts to everything from ""Bachelorette"" competition rules to a psychic's advise to help her choose between Larry, a handsome newscaster (Dean Cain), and charming former baseball star ""The Gooch"" (Mark Consuelos, Ripa's real-life husband)
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joanna Johnson | Writer | ||
| Mark Consuelos | Guest Star | ||
| Andrea Martin | Guest Star | ||
| Dean Cain | Guest Star | ||
| Gil Junger | Director |