When Keith can't decide between two girls (Tammy and Mary), Tanya and Maddie compete over which one he should choose and to take to a school '70s party. Each mom tries to convince Keith to choose the girl most like herself. Meanwhile, Ed helps Danika smooth things over with her boyfriend after they get in a fight.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marc Firek | Writer | ||
| Alex Barnow | Writer | ||
| Cory Hardrict | Guest Star | ||
| Maggie Grace | Guest Star | ||
| Shannon Simon | Guest Star | ||
| Barnet Kellman | Director |