Maggie’s life is forever changed when she has a prediction she didn’t see coming.
As Maggie struggles to offer hope to a client, Ben and Jessie’s new presence in the duplex pushes her to move her psychic business out of her home and into a local storefront, where she meets a potential new love interest.
A tentative Maggie is coerced into a double date by Louise with Daniel and John. After the double date, Louise breaks things off with John based on a face Maggie made while having a vision. Louise ultimately reveals that she’s been making life decisions based on Maggie’s reactions to her visions. Maggie has to work on hiding her “tells” from Louise alongside figuring out if she’s ready to date again.
Maggie is all set to go on her first fancy date with Daniel but when she gets a vision of a fight on her date, she preemptively cancels. Meanwhile, Amy scoops up a date-less Louise for a couples dinner with Dave, which both parties misunderstand. Ben tries to celebrate an anniversary dinner that Jesse would rather forget, but luckily Maria and Jack are there to help.
Maggie mentors a teenager who’s just started having visions, which leads to conflict between Maggie and her mother as Maggie reflects on her own teen years. Amy hits Louise’s car and goes overboard trying to make it up to her.
Maggie’s pursuit of a vision involving Ben causes Amy and Dave to get addicted to her readings. Meanwhile, Ben struggles to find joy going through boxes from his childhood with Jessie and Louise. With Ben stuck in the past and Amy and Dave suddenly obsessed with the future, Maggie must figure out how to use her powers responsibly, which inevitably helps all of them figure out how to live in the present.
When Maggie introduces Daniel to her parents on her birthday, it goes worse than she ever could have predicted.
Maggie and Louise get a second chance at prom when Ben invites them to help him chaperone at his school. The girls are excited to have a do-over, considering their real prom was such a bust.
Maggie grapples with putting herself out there at her job. Without a sign or any advertisement at her storefront, she gets countless confused walk-ins and must overcome her fears of owning who she is. At the same time, she must help her mom rediscover who she is after Maria quits her job and gets into tarot reading. Louise, on the hunt for a new roommate, finds the perfect candidate, but can’t decide if he’d make a better boyfriend or a better roommate.
Maggie is excited to receive an invitation to a fancy gathering for mystics only. Meanwhile, Louise hands over control of her dating apps to Jessie, Ben, Amy and Dave.
Maggie is excited about Amy's bachelorette weekend getaway. She's been inundated with visions and needs a break.
It's been a week since Maggie lost her visions and she hasn't gotten any clarity. Desperate, she goes through the stages of grief and tries everything she can to get them back.
Having accepted the loss of her visions, Maggie looks forward to Amy and Dave's wedding. But everything goes downhill at the rehearsal dinner when Jessie reveals that she knows the secret the whole group has been hiding.
