Mister Rogers returns to his garage to replay Chef Brockett's first appearance in the television house. In the Neighborhood of Make Believe, Margaret H. Witch returns to help clean up the disabled crystal ball. But she can't do it without Lady Elaine, who had painted one side of the crystal ball red and the other half blue. When Lady Elaine confesses, she plays the last part in getting the crystal ball back to normal.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fred Rogers | Writer | ||
| Margaret Hamilton | Guest Star | ||
| Mari Gardner | Guest Star | ||
| Bill Moates | Director |