Annie helps Caitlin hide the pregnancy pad from Cole, and Caitlin decides to tell Cole the truth, while putting the pregnancy pad back in the bathroom. However, Annie, who told a few lies to Cole about hat they were talking about, tells her that she shouldn't say anything, because she might lose Cole. Caitlin interprets Annie's words and thinks that Annie will help her find a baby to pass off as her own, and Annie is ready to do that, just to get Caitlin's support for the inheritance. Tim find the bloody gaff in Mark's bag, which leads Tim to suspect that Mark is the killer. Casey and Michael run after Mark, who left the house to find the murder. Meg and Vanessa follow them without saying anything. The islanders find out that Jade was a thief. Suddenly, Amy finds Mark's camera and the islanders watch the tape of Elizabeth getting murdered by a killer in a skull mask. Meg calls out Mark's name when she hears a sound, but she doesn't know that it's actually the killer.