In New York City, any pool sharks worth their weight in chalk call Steinway Billiards home. Money, egos and reputations are on the line when the nation's #2 player shows up from Boston to challenge the home team.
Top pro player Mike Dechaine extends his stay in New York with his sights on the coveted top five list. But when he and Steinway's #1 player almost come to blows, Mike decides to go after NYC's top female player, Jennifer Barretta.
With competition at Steinway heating up and financial pressure on the home front, Gary is having a hard time keeping his head in the game, so Finnegan boosts his friend's confidence with a road trip warm-up.
Scotty Simonetti has only one arm, but he doesn't need to negotiate a match handicap to challenge Gary for cash and the #2 spot. Plus, Gary tries yoga with his wife to help focus his mind on winning at pool.
Pro pool players Mike Dechaine and Jarrod Clowery decide to officially become New Yorkers, making them eligible for a spot on Steinway's top 5 list. Plus, Finnegan concocts a new hustle against one handed pool shark Scotty Simonetti.
After beating Gary, one-handed pool hustler Scotty decides it's time to fight his way to the top, challenging Jennifer Barretta for first place and $1K. Plus, Amy hires a hypnotherapist to give Ross the edge he needs to win.
Jenn and husband Gregg seek couples counseling when the pressure to be the best takes its toll on their relationship. Plus, fiery Irishman Gary almost comes to blows with members of the peanut gallery during his list match with Jenn.
A "pool" party at Emily's place leads to a girls vs. guys doubles match, but when Emily and Smiley start beating Mike and Jarrod, it get ugly between the Boston besties. Plus, Amy visits a Voodoo shop to give Ross a spiritual edge.
Steinway's top players head to A.C. to take on Jersey's top-ranked hustlers for a $5K prize. And Ross and Amy crash the party - but Ross has a lot on his mind, as he makes a surprise proposal that for once leaves Amy speechless.
In the season finale of "The Hustlers," Finnegan sets up a $20,000 sudden death elimination tournament and invites outsiders to buy in. But a controversial handicap system leads to clashes, resulting in a surprise ultimate champion.