In a twist of "The Monkey's Paw," two boys scare an old lady to death the night before Halloween just as the next night they receive a hand granting them wishes with consequences.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chloe Brown | Writer | ||
| Gordon Masten | Guest Star | ||
| Ann Page | Guest Star | ||
| Jason Tremblay | Guest Star | ||
| Linda Smith | Guest Star | ||
| Maxwell Medeiros | Guest Star | ||
| Paul Stewart | Guest Star | ||
| Noah Plener | Guest Star | ||
| D.J. MacHale | Director |