Rick, Becca, Curtis, Wylie, and Sage awake to find themselves trapped in coffins. Melanie asks the audience for help finding her missing friend and breaks into Sage’s home.
Rick gets a call from home while Wylie gets dunked and discovers a tide chart. Curtis needs his medicine and Travis has his say about Melanie. Sage finds a note in her coffin, Prowler invites Melanie into the game, and Becca receives video of the others.
Rick & Wylie meet while Curtis & Becca talk Valentines. Sage & Becca decipher a note written in Spanish and Wylie & Rick work to figure out the tide chart. Melanie spots a truck outside her home and looks up Hayden Weir.
Rick and Wylie find a pregnancy test and argue about its meaning. Melanie tracks down the truck outside her home. Wylie destroys her coffin and is able to escape. Melanie connects Hayden Weir to all of the kidnappings.
Hayden talks with Becca while Mel & Travis break into Hayden’s home. Rick talks Wylie through first aid to try and save her leg. Sage is dug up and Wylie’s coffin begins to flood.
Mel electrocutes Rick while she and Travis discover a gravesite. Mel & Travis race to save Sage from being killed. Travis has a hunch where to find Becca and the killer is revealed.