Lucy is upset when she concludes she is losing her slayer powers. Ian tries to assuage Lucy's fears by telling her she is fine and everything will be alright and they make love. However, this time their lovemaking doesn't satisfy Ian's hunger further upsetting Lucy. While Caleb tries the keys to unlock Livvie's cell, Rafe regains consciousness and tells Caleb that he hid the key because he knew Caleb would double-cross him. Caleb frustrated that he can't rescue Livvie, confronts Joshua and they fight. During the altercation, Joshua slashes Caleb's throat. Allison and Rafe find Caleb still alive and Allison pleads with Rafe to help Caleb.