The Town That Never Was" is the first installment of Tales from the SMP, and was streamed live on December 26, 2020. It was a small settlement in the wilderness of the Dream SMP, built in an hour by Karl, Awesamdude, BadBoyHalo, GeorgeNotFound, and Fundy. The hour long build culminated in Karl blowing up parts of the town with TNT. He then dubbed it "The Town That Never Was", and said that it would be forgotten by all of them, but that the lore would remain. The lore of "The Town That Never Was" is similar to the history of L'Manberg.