After the Petes and Ellen scare away Mr. Tastee, the ice cream man, they go on a search to bring him back to Wellsville.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jeremy Collins | Guest Star | ||
| Fran Anthony | Guest Star | ||
| Caitlin Collins | Guest Star | ||
| Kate Pierson | Guest Star | ||
| Russell Horton | Guest Star | ||
| Aaron Schwartz | Guest Star | ||
| Heather Matarazzo | Guest Star | ||
| Jillian Collins | Guest Star | ||
| Marcus Presley | Guest Star | ||
| Michael Stipe | Guest Star | ||
| David Bannick | Guest Star | ||
| Katherine Dieckmann | Director |