Josh, Milana, Sandeep, and Elaine drink spiked apple ciders and cringe at their past instant messenger usernames.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lily Du | Host | ||
| Grant O'Brien | Host | Bartender | |
| Milana Vayntrub | Guest Star | ||
| Elaine Carroll | Guest Star | ||
| Sandeep Parikh | Guest Star | ||
| Josh Ruben | Guest Star |