Business owner Larry Hughes goes missing from his Pulaski, Tennessee, home. His distraught wife Mary Ann enlists police to investigate, but little do they know it will take a quarter-century to put the pieces of this sinister puzzle together.
Da en mand forsvinder i Pulaski i Tennessee, mener nogle, at han løb væk med sin elskerinde, andre at der er sket ham noget. 25 år senere finder efterforskerne sandheden.