Melody and Starlight share gossip with the other girls about their juicy stories, except for Sweetheart who doesn't like telling on others. Patch who tries to imagine Teddy and his secrets, assumes he has a teddy bear and the girls jeer. Ace overhears this and tells Lancer at football practice. They both poke fun at Teddy and he gives them a punch up and heads home. Teddy is mad at Sweetheart, who worsens his mood. To sort this out, Sweetheart forms a plan with her friends. Bright Eyes and Melody lure Ace and Lancer to babysit some baby ponies. They take good care of the babies but when feeding time comes, the girls force the two boys to eat and dress like babies and Sweetheart takes a picture of them which would ruin their reputation. In exchange for dropping the story of having a teddy bear, Teddy tears the photograph and is relieved his secret is safe and trusts Sweetheart more than before. Episode Song: "A Juicy Story", sung by all the girls.