A large group of clients from New England return to Scott and George’s boats for a second day of competition, as the rivalry between the mentor and his prodigy rises to a new level. Scott, determined to exact revenge for the previous day’s loss, shows his clients the old Captain still has game. George’s confidence is tested, as he struggles to interpret and react to the changing weather conditions. Meanwhile, Augie needs to please his most important client from New York, who’s flown in from New York City to practice for the next day’s high-stakes sailfishing tournament. Nick heads out 35 miles in pursuit of “Forklift Fred”, the 500-pound monster-swordfish that has, thus far, eluded him.