Although Caitlin wants Annie out, Annie threatens to expose Caitlin's lie to Cole, so Caitlin changes her mind quickly and talk to Gregory about Annie, claiming that she wouldn't have anything against him pursuing a deeper relationship with Annie. Gregory thanks Annie for her support lately, and she says that she can't be his mistress anymore; she wants to be his wife. Ricardo and Casey arrive at the cabin, where they realize that nobody was in that cabin for years. Ricardo feels fooled, and demands to know where Meg actually is, but Ben has no idea. Ben tries to poison Meg by offering her a soup, which Meg drops on the floor, "accidentally."