Since he works at a gym, JD gets the idea to film his version of the popular gym-porn scenario. Guest appearances by comedians Mitch Fatel, Brandt Tobler, and adult film star, Penny Poison.
JD thinks he got herpes from a one-night stand and asks Dylan to go with him to Planned Parenthood. Dylan has his own selfish reasons for tagging along.
After a social justice warrior accuses Dylan of being racist in a staff meeting, Dylan wants to prove her wrong. But he;s just not very good at it.
Dylan asks Molly out on a date but Molly lies and says she has to go to church. Dylan tries to track her down at church. Instead, he accidentally ends up joining a meeting of a whole different kind in a church's basement.
Deon has to test the fire alarms, which leads to a misunderstanding with Buddy thinking he's been fired as the manager. Dylan enrolls in a group fitness class for all the wrong reasons.
Dylan tries to make Molly jealous by showing her a picture he took of a stripper and claiming it's his new girlfriend. But, unbeknownst to Dylan, the girl in the picture is actually Molly, in a wig.
Dylan and JD are frustrated their personal training business is drying up due to the popularity of the gym's new trainer. But the new guy isn't all he appears to be.
JD dates a co-worker who thinks he's a loser for working at a gym; Dylan becomes jealous after seeing Molly flirt with a gym member, but her flirtation isn't all that it appears to be.
JD starts dating the "new girl" and Dylan tries to break it to him that she's not what she appears. But JD doesn't quite pickup on Dylan's not so subtle hints.