Hannah lands a job at the world's only wish-granting company, but will the complex rules and red-tape of magic make Hannah's first week her last? Fairy Godmother learns that congress has killed the Penny, putting Wish It in a financial crunch.
In an attempt to foil Shari's plans to win Granter of the Month, JoJo the Birthday Clown jinxes the genie with bad mojo. Meanwhile, Godmother struggles with the Penny crisis and Yvette ruffles Travis's feathers.
Yvette hires new intern Wendy to handle Dandelion wishes while Travis struggles to earn his wings. Teddy's pep talk with Hannah leads to a tour of the fate department.
On the eve of Chinese New Year, rival fortune cookie company Oshi O-Mikuji gets a scare out of the gang. Hannah and Shari hold the fate of one man's life in their sweaty palms as Travis takes Wendy under his proverbial wings.
A housewife's wish for life to be more like a soap opera shakes things up at the office. Shari, Travis, and Hannah eagerly compete for Granter of the Month while JoJo and Yvette swap jobs to see who's got it harder.
Teddy and Hannah decide to have their first date at Wish It Inc. only to find out that a date at Wish It Inc. is sloppy, complicated, and looks a lot like JoJo. Travis and Yvette fight over their newest toy, Wendy, while Shari tries to convince Fairy Godmother to give her extra time off by utilizing her genie assets.
With Wish It's finances trimmed to the bone, Godmother is forced to let someone go and bestows the impossible task to the only person heartless enough to do it, Yvette. Travis, Wendy, and Shari plan on keeping their jobs by scapegoating everyone's least favorite employee, Karla.
It's lights out when Travis and Hannah's heated rivalry spawns a wish-off powerful enough to knock out the magic generator. Unlikely pairs form in the dark, but will they all survive the monstrous Craig before Wendy and Fairy Godmother can get the magic flowing again?
In an attempt to win his fairy wings, Travis and Wendy wage a witch-hunt to weed out the Oshi O-Mikuji spy. Yvette helps Fairy Godmother's plight to fix the perpetual penny problem while Hannah and Teddy realize everyone has gone missing.
Hannah is faced with the difficult reality that happily ever after isn't always what you hoped for and is stuck refunding wishes with the expert: Wendy. Travis, Jojo and Shari struggle to get by without using magic as Godmother starts calling in favors to help get the Penny back.
Teddy makes a startling discovery about himself that turns his life upside-down. Travis and Wendy sulk after their unsuccessful search for the spy and JoJo gets his revenge on Shari for thwarting his jinx on her.
With the Penny back, Fairy Godmother plans an office party, which JoJo hijacks. Hannah tries to prove to Teddy that he is magical by peeking at Fate. Travis discovers who the Oshi O-Mikuji spy is, but is he too late to stop their sinister plot!? It all comes to a head at the party with a bang.